Tuesday, April 25, 2006

The 'Nasheed Culture'


Interesting article I was emailed today.


The ‘Nasheed Culture’By a concerned anonymous Muslim

http://www.themuslimweekly.com/fullstoryview.aspx?NewsID=272A78AD26AE85FF55DE775F&MENUID=COMMENT&DESCRIPTION=Comments

Islam is more than just a religion; it is a code, a full legislator for every aspect and sphere of one’s life. Allah (SWT) ordained duties upon His believers which must be followed in order to gain His pleasures, His Mercy and our inevitable abode (Heaven or Hell). One of the many duties is Da’wa; inviting people to the way of Islam. Parallel to this is Hisbah; enjoying the good and forbidding the evil. Is it rational to adhere to one and dismiss the other? As we know Allah (SWT) says in his Glorified Book.

"Oh you who believe! Enter into Islam whole-heartedly; and follow not the footsteps of the evil one (shaytaan/devil) for he is to you an open enemy"(Qur’an 2:208)

Alhamdulillah (All praises be to Allah), many people have become full time Da’ees (inviters) who propagate the true message of Islam to the masses. People have different methods, some like to go out onto the streets, and others like to hold circles and talks; both are effective and pleasing in the sight of Allah (SWT). However others, like our brother Sami Yusuf, like to sprinkle a bit of Haram with a bit of Halal to comprise his method. Scratching your heads…

Islam does not permit Muslims to indulge in music; there may be some ikhtilaaf (difference of opinion) of the issue of the duff (drum-like instrument), where some scholars have said it to be lawful under certain times, conditions and the extent of its use. But the piano, violin, xylophones, wind instruments, pluck instruments are absolutely forbidden in Islam. Scholars have no ikhtilaaf in this. Then why is our brother Sami Yusuf engaging in this Haram with his presumably honourable Halal intentions? Before I go any further, brothers and sisters this is not an attack on the brother, Sami Yusuf himself, but the whole music driven nasheed industry.

Many Muslims listen to nasheeds everyday, thinking it is good and our natural inclination is to increase our love for them. But this is creating for us a dangerous problem. Our new brothers and sisters that enter into the Deen are somehow becoming indoctrinated into this nasheed frenzy. We see people memorising lyrics, reciting them and sometimes even rejoicing over them, and it may seem that there is nothing at all wrong with this. But when the extent of the obsessions compromises our Deen, our recitations and memorisation of the Qur’an, the actual Sunnah of the rejoicing of Islam; and when the reliance upon the nasheeds becomes the primary sources for knowledge, inspiration and dhikr [remembrance of ALLAH (SWT)] the problems are indeed becoming very apparent. Excessive nasheeds can even lead to an actual dislike of Qur’an, a frightening statement, but one that which could really be true. Our young generations are slowly starting to distant themselves away from the Qur’an and immersing themselves into this "nasheed culture". We find ourselves in a situation where the nasheed boom has practically taken over our youth.

And brothers such as Sami Yusuf are not helping to stamp out the doubts but they are actually helping fuel the fire, as they blend the clear cut Haram to gist up their styles of nasheeds, feeding our youth with their deviant da’wa campaigns. They are teaching our youth the beauty of Islam through this detested Haram and through the most God forsaken means. Just watch the heads of the people who are listening to these "blended" nasheeds; they start with slight movements backwards and forwards, moving with the rhythms of the music, this slowly evolving into full body motion intertwining with the music and at the extremes bursting into fully blown dancing. Astaghfirullah!

Islam denounces the use of music and as Muslims we must not indulge in this Haram. We must stop encouraging the people who are creating this veiled fitnah for our community, even though their intentions may actually be noble. Muslims have many a times been led through that slippery slope and that is the reason why we find Muslims in such a shameful situation today. We have to correct the shortcomings of our brothers and encourage them to develop a Halal method to demonstrate the beauty of our Deen (religion) and to spread the message of Islam. Indeed Allah says in His Qur’an:

"Verily Satan is an enemy to you: so treat him as an enemy. He only invites his adherents that they may become Companions of the Blazing Fire." (Qur’an 35:6)

14 Comments:

At 1:42 a.m., Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hmm...I don't always see the need for mentioning names when from the article the 'culprit' will easily be able to conclude that it's his actions that the person is protesting against.

The concerned Muslim refrained from disclosing their name, it didn't stop the message from getting across. If a name had been mentioned it would have seemed very much more confrontational, a critique of SY's existence.

"However others, like our brother Sami Yusuf, like to sprinkle a bit of Haram with a bit of Halal to comprise his method....Then why is our brother Sami Yusuf engaging in this Haram with his presumably honourable Halal intentions? Before I go any further, brothers and sisters this is not an attack on the brother, Sami Yusuf himself.... "

Hmm, that's highly debateable,lol. I'm not sure it's possible for Br.SY to take heed of the advice given in the article after that kind of abuse.

If no names had been mentioned at all it would have been a justified admonition that lots of people could have applied to themselves.

I've read scholars' advice on Anasheed and they've said almost exactly what the CM said, but they didn't mention any names. Is there a need?

Call me watercolour, but the naming ruined the aim.

I'm not sure I'm the right material for this blog site, lol.

 
At 12:36 p.m., Blogger Ki said...

I agree completely with the article (cos i have heard of screaming / overly exited sisters (!!!) at SY's concerts!!!!)

But i also agree with Khadijah's comment that the name should be left out, SY isn't the first, and definetly not the last

 
At 1:04 p.m., Blogger That Mash Guy said...

I copied this and emailed it to two friends that follow Sufiism, their replies were:

Bruv, don't send stuff like this to me. It makes me angry. Got no time to be reading the ramblings of some confused fool, and on top of that I have sandwiches without relish which id really making my blood boil.

and...

ask them wot rumi loved n played?

Me personally, Well I don't listen to this stuff, thought I am aware of it, thus I dont have any position as of yet. Guess I'll look into it.

I'm betting the writer was a Wahaabi though.

 
At 7:22 p.m., Blogger Abu Abdullah said...

I agree with Khadijah - there was no need to mention the name; i think anyone who picked up the author's point would have automatically seen SY as an example.

That said, the points raised are very relevant. I recall being told by a sister that at a fosis conference a few years ago, sisters were "one step short of throwing their hijabs on stage" - that wasnt SY but another lovable nasheed group from the states.

In addition to the points raised by the author, the problem seems to be that many Muslims involved in Islamic work spend much of their time and thousands of pounds organising "nasheed extravaganzas" and concerts, which would be much better spent on tarbiyah, da'awah, and you know what else.

People have a perception that this is the way forward in da'awah by showing the kuffar that we Muslims have entertainment and halal music. Forgive me if I disagree but I cannot imagine the sahaabah and ta'abieen bopping along to the latest nasheed in an attempt to make Islam more appealing to the mushrikeen. In truth, this latest craze is nothing but symptoms of the inferiority complex we are suffering as Muslims - that Islam in its purest form is something embarrassing and backward and that we need to modify it to suit the times.

That said, I do believe nasheeds may be a good way to wean many brothers and sisters off music. Sometimes, it is very difficult to give up something you have thought is halal your whole life and i think in thta sense, nasheeds do serve some purpose. But there is the danger which is all too apparent today.

 
At 7:24 p.m., Blogger Abu Abdullah said...

The mash guy - bruv, i thought the sufi brothers could have coem up with more intelligent arguments than this simply being "the ramblings of a confused fool" or the writer being a "wahhabi".

 
At 10:27 p.m., Anonymous Anonymous said...

I'm glad we agree.

 
At 3:50 p.m., Anonymous Anonymous said...

I saw SY at the Islamic Relief concert earlier this month. I used to be a big fan but was very very put off at the concert when after his performance, he shouted into the mic, "are we proud to be Muslims?" (nothing wrong here) but then "are we proud to be British?" at which the crowd went more or less quiet. He then roared again, "come on guys, arent we proud to be British?" and then some sisters started screaming. Alhumdulillah, the brothers kept their dignity.

But just wondering whether this nasheed artist is now being used as a political pawn to push "the radical middle path"

 
At 11:26 p.m., Anonymous Anonymous said...

I saw SY on Islam Channel a few days ago and he sounded very sincere, masha'Allaah. He doesn't see a problem with music and said that those people who sell 'nasheeds' and don't call it music, even though it contains music are deceiving the people and that's wrong: "if some people don't believe music is halal then we should respect that. I don't have a problem with it that's why I make it, for the love of Allaah (very paraphrased)".

Actions are but by intentions at least.

I guess artists want to use their medium to diffuse the tension over identity and some believe citizenship and Islam to be symbiotically connected...

Hmm... Identity is in a bit of a crisis where Muslims are concerned these days, especially the younger ones.

I'm surprised such a question was posed to the audience considering what Britain has been up to around the world to think only recently, lol. It'd be shocking if anyone was happy! Even the BNP "want our boys home", lol. The response should have been anticipated really.


wassalam.

 
At 12:23 a.m., Anonymous Anonymous said...

Assalaamualaykum,

All i can say is, my thoughts exactly, nasheeds have become a form of entertainment and recently some 'Islamic' events have started to come with titles such as 'evening of entertainment'. Are we not moving away from the real purpose - to please Allah?

 
At 6:03 p.m., Anonymous Anonymous said...

Walaikumassalam wr wb.

Hmm.

 
At 12:49 a.m., Anonymous Anonymous said...

Salam

I read the article, hmm... naming does have it downside, I agree with Khadiijah, but naming does also ensure that everyone knows what this person really means. And brings to life all the other fitna I have read in this blog, like the sisters short of opening their hijabs.
It seems that the auther tried to critise SY as well as the whole industry, that was pretty obvious...

Personally I found this a awake up call to the people this article really applies to.

I know music is to be Haram, as my Imam in my local East London Mosque Skiekh Abdul Qayum has made it very clear indeed during numerous talks and sermons. Along with many knowledgable brothers and sisters. Does make you womder why SY is using music?

Point to wonder upon...

Anas (R.A.) reports that Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) said: “There will certainly be people from my Ummah who will attempt to legalize fornication, the wearing of silk (for males), the consuming of wine and the use of musical instruments”

Subhanallah...

Salam.

 
At 1:48 p.m., Anonymous Anonymous said...

There's a purely factual way of using names- if they MUST be used- and there's another more... unecessary way. That's really the only bit that was off-putting.

I think SY has sincere belief that music is not haram. It might be the Egyptian influence?

All of my Egyptian friends listen to music and consider it completely halal. MOST local scholars in Egypt have ruled that music- with good content, is fine, they say.

When I told them about Muslims in Britain and that we hold music as something impermissible, they all responded with shock and then cast us into the "extreme", wahabi and Ikhwani corner.

The only way he'll stop is if he choses to and the only reason he'll do that is if another scholar can refute his scholars' ruling. Same with all the Egyptians I know (but they tend not to want to get into it).

Wassalam.

 
At 9:54 a.m., Blogger shaz said...

Salaam.
I agree nasheeds have become a form of entertainment, with too many of them involving Haram music and instruments- are they really needed to be included?

I know a lot of nasheed artists may have a pure intention behind their nasheeds and Allah (S.W.T.) knows best, many of them do convey a good message and also a reminder, but I think they really need to think deep about the effect that the musical instruments may have on the listener, i.e. becoming obsessed with listening to them - for entertainment and moving away from the two things that they will actually really benefit from - the Holy Qur'an and the Sunnah.

As Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W.) said:
"Some people of this Ummah will be swallowed by the earth, transformed into animals, and some will be bombarded with stones". One of the Muslims asked, " When will that be O messenger of Allah?" he (S.A.W.) said " When singers and MUSICAL INSTRUMENTS will become popular, and much wine is drunk."

Subhan Allah we all know that this is true and singers and musical instruments are very popular, this is one of the smaller signs of the coming of Qiyamah.
I really hope that the nasheed artists think abouth this sign before they start including musical instruments in their nasheeds, and refrain from it.

May Allah (S.W.T.) forgive us for our sins and short comings.
AMEEN.

 
At 9:54 a.m., Blogger shaz said...

Salaam.
I agree nasheeds have become a form of entertainment, with too many of them involving Haram music and instruments- are they really needed to be included?

I know a lot of nasheed artists may have a pure intention behind their nasheeds and Allah (S.W.T.) knows best, many of them do convey a good message and also a reminder, but I think they really need to think deep about the effect that the musical instruments may have on the listener, i.e. becoming obsessed with listening to them - for entertainment and moving away from the two things that they will actually really benefit from - the Holy Qur'an and the Sunnah.

As Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W.) said:
"Some people of this Ummah will be swallowed by the earth, transformed into animals, and some will be bombarded with stones". One of the Muslims asked, " When will that be O messenger of Allah?" he (S.A.W.) said " When singers and MUSICAL INSTRUMENTS will become popular, and much wine is drunk."

Subhan Allah we all know that this is true and singers and musical instruments are very popular, this is one of the smaller signs of the coming of Qiyamah.
I really hope that the nasheed artists think abouth this sign before they start including musical instruments in their nasheeds, and refrain from it.

May Allah (S.W.T.) forgive us for our sins and short comings.
AMEEN.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home